© Copyright 2026. James Johnson Green Ltd, All rights reserved. Company Reg Number: 10452936. VAT Reg: GB494285158. Policies: Modern Slavery Statement | HTML Sitemap
© Copyright 2026. James Johnson Green Ltd, All rights reserved. Company Reg Number: 10452936. VAT Reg: GB494285158. Policies: Modern Slavery Statement | HTML Sitemap
Both Music Magpie and Envirofone offer tech trade-in services, but there are key differences in pricing, speed, and customer experience. Use this side-by-side comparison to find the right fit for you.
Over 4 million customers have sold with Envirofone, with support teams ready to help at every step.
We test each item individually and even welcome damaged devices, so you get a fair price every time.
Same-day bank transfers once your device is processed, helping you get paid without the wait.*
If you are not happy with our offer, we will return your device free of charge—no strings attached.
Trading tech since 2005 with processes built for accuracy and transparency.
Every device is reused, refurbished, or recycled, keeping valuable tech in circulation longer.
SSL encryption, safe payments, and strict data handling give you confidence from quote to payout.
Free postage with our Enviropack and easy drop-off choices to keep things flexible.
Key differences between Envirofone and Music Magpie at a glance.
| What matters | Envirofone | Music Magpie |
|---|---|---|
| Years in operation | 21 years — more experience with tech trade-ins | 19 years |
| Trade-in pricing | Dynamic faulty pricing for accurate valuations | Fixed pricing limits flexibility |
| Trade-in bonus | Envirocash bonus adds extra value | No cash or credit bonus |
| Trustpilot rating | 4.6 — higher customer satisfaction | 4.4 |
| Marketplace focus | Specialist in tech only (phones, tablets, consoles) | Tech, games, CDs/DVDs |
| Faulty and broken devices | Accepts faulty and broken devices | Accepts a range of conditions |
| Supported devices | Phones, wearables, consoles, tablets, MacBooks, laptops | Phones, tablets, consoles, smartwatches, MacBooks, laptops |
| Quality control | 70+ point PhoneCheck inspection on all refurbished devices | Uses PhoneCheck with a 70+ point check |
| Delivery speed | Next-day delivery available | Next-day delivery available |
| Payment speed | Same working day payment for fast, reliable payouts | Same working day as device is received |
| Warranty | 12-month warranty | 12-month warranty |
| Free postage | Free postage included with every trade-in | Free postage on all phone trade-ins |
*Subject to devices being processed before 3pm and banking provider timescales.
Answers to frequently asked questions when comparing Music Magpie and Envirofone.
Get an instant quote, send your device for free, and enjoy secure payments with Envirofone. We keep things quick, transparent, and sustainable.
